Mahi
18th June 2010, 05:40 AM
guys
just back afer watching Ravan with saroj and samurai, we had dinner together. saroj is with me in my flat now, he is having a hot tea, and the time is 3 am here, very difficult for a review.
theatre: lamcy cinemas, karama-dubai
show time : 11 pm
status: house full
mahis views
sadharana mani ratnam films kanan pokumbol ulla oru expectation undallo,athu athe pole thanne nila nirthi ennu njan parayum.
plot ivide binoy paranjallo, thudakkathile scenes ellam nalla interesting ayirunnu. ramayanam plot modern versionil avatharipichirikkunnu. ini njan kanda kure sthiram cliche scenes parayam.
eccentric and psycho aya oru nayakan, ayal onnukil ethenkilum kunninte mukalil kayari irikkum, athallenkil ethenkilum kallinmel kunthichiriikkum, kuracu neram silent ayi irikkum,pettennu alarum,athu ketu adthullavar njettum, samsarikkumbol idak kannu thuripichu kattum, alenkil pottichirikkum,aa pazhaya set up thanne. :deviltalk:
ee nayakanu tension vannal ayal mottathala thadavi kondirikkum, ayalude priyappettavar arenkilum marchal alari karayum, 2 kayyum thalayude pinnil pidich karayum, athum vaya paramavadhi polichu vechu.:thinking:
pinne mugathu pala color chayam thehcu varum, idak karupp, idak velup, idak manja, enthu pandarathinanavo ee chayam? veruthe manushyane menakeduthanayitu.:sathan:
inne pathiv pole nayakanu vendi ( atho villano) chakan nadakunna koottalikal, avar full time kattilayirikum, avarum mugath chayamoke thechanu nadakkunnath, ennal alle oru mani ratnam touch kittu? avanmaarum idakidak oliyitt kondirikkum,:haha:
nayakanu santhosham varumbol avarellavarum koode kattuvasikale pole kuntham pidichu thullichadum, idak kurach cheriya pillar screenlode odipkum, idak chila vayassaya ammoommamare kond 2 vari padipiku, avarude 2 stepsum, athu kure mani ratnam filmsil ullatnallo? camera idakidak ilakki konde irikkum, kanunnavanu enthanu nadakkunnath ennu oru vasthu manassilakaruthallo?:death:
pinne ee thatikondu pokal, athum nammal kure kandathu thanne, areyano thatti kond poyathu, avar gap kittumbol odipokum, avar ethu vazhiyiloode poyalum chennu pedunnath thati kondu ponna alude munpil ayirikum, ithilum athu thannekadha,:hbang:
njan koduthal onnum parayunnilla, nalla bangiyulla frames undayirunnu,music was good, after interwell anu onnu intersting ayath, climaxile fight nannnayirunnu.
climax was just above average.
perfomance
abhishek was ok
vikram was superb
aishaya as usual
govinda - natural
music and camera was really good.
mani ratnam athra valiya oru sambavam cheythu ennu enik thonniyilla,:roll:
media ithra hype kodukkunathum alkarude aswadhanathe badhikkunnund, enik ithil kooduthal onnum parayan aryilla.padathe kurichu adhikarikamayi samsarikkan njan sarojine vilikkunu.
my rating : 2/5
my verdict: flop :silenced:
sarojs view
adhyam thanne parayate, kanan pokunna cinemaye kurichu oru vyakthamaya dharana munp vanna vilayiruthalukalil ninnu kittiyathinalakam amthamaya pratheekshakalonnum illayirunnu, enkilum rahmante ganangalum sangeeth sivante framesum theatril thanne aswadhikkuka ennathu mathram ayirunnu lakshyam.
ini cinemayilek....
kadhasaram pala avarthi paranjathu kond kooduthal prathipadhikkunnilla, enkilum kadhayekuichu chilath parayaund. ramayanathil ninnu prajodhanam ulkondanu ee cinema cheythath ennu maniratnam avakashapedunnekilum ramayanathinte chla amshangal mathrame enik ithil kanan sadhicullu.padipathinja oru pazhamkadhayo punnyapurana mahakavyamo adarthi edth mattoru veekshana oniloode athine avatharipikumbol theerchayayum athinte saramshathod neethi pularthanam,alathavakonnum thanne asthiwtham undavilla.
malayalathil m.t chanthuvine puthiya oru thalathil avatharipichu vijayipichath nammal kandathanu, peredut oru porayma polum arayan akatha oru classic chithram, pakshe ivde mani ratnathinu ambe pali. oru kadha karante mano vijarathinu anusarichu kadhapathrangale engane venamenkilum matti marikam, nyakane villain akkam, villaine nayakan akanm, sahajaryangal kondu nyayeekarikkukayum avam. pakshe athorikkalum prerana ulkonda maha avyathinte ashayathine thanne natti prathishttikkunna reethyil akaruth.
kadhayilek...
kettathum paranjathumokke ravanante kannilode oru modern ramayanam ennayirunnu, enkilum arayatte, ee kadha enik ramyanam ayi kanan kazhiyunnilla.
udhaharanathinu ramayanathil raman ravananod yudham cheyyunath polum seethaye thatti kond poyi enna ru karanam ond mathramanu, pakshe maniratnathinte raman thangalude sakthi theliyikkan raqinte mel kadannu kayariya america pole , thante varavu ariyikkan, beerayod ( raavan) poruthan irangunna oru sadharana cinematic nayakan mathramayi othungi. athu kond thanne avanil ramante oru amshavum kanan enik kazhinjilla.
itharam oru sahajaryathiloode thanne mani ratnam cinemayle nayakan aya raavananu munthookam kodukuvanum athiloode raavanane nyayeekarikkanum attum. ee oru udhaharanathiloode thanne ethra mathram ravanante kadha ramayanathod chernnu nilkkunnu ennu vyakathamyennu karthunnu.
munkalaa mani ratnam chithramaya kadhathanthu enna andavum ranayanam enna beejavum ru test tubeil samyojipichu kalam thetti piravi kodutha oru mixtre mathramanu thinte kadha, spastamayennu karuthatte..
direction.
mani ratnam enna samvidhayakante oru pizhavanu ee chithrathinu ingane oru vidhi sammanikunnath. shaji kailasinu abimanikam, adhehathinpin thudaran mani ratnathe pole oru pragalba samvdhayakanum ethunnu. close up shotukalum , shaky camera movementsum abstract shotukalum ( dont know whether this term is correct), kond kadha parayan sramichath thanne prekshakanu maduppum ulavakkunnud. oru avasarathil oru arojakam ayi marunnund. oru pakshe kadha arayunna reethiyil oru puthuma ondu varan sramichathanenkil polum athu oru parajayam ayennuparaathe vaya.
perfomances.
abishek bachan - chila avsarangalil over the top ayi tonni enkilum muzhachu nilkatha abinayam.
vikram - pala thalangal illatha oru sadharana villain kadhapathrathe anayasamayi avatharipichu, enkilum chila scens manoharamayirunnu.
aiswaraya - facial expressionekal kooduthalum physical strain anu padathil kanan kazhinjath. enkilum mikachathenno mosham enno parayan pattatha oru perfomance.
co starsil govinda eduth payan thakka savisesathakal onnumillatha oru sadharana prakadanam, priyamani nannayirunnu, ravi kishan swatha sidhamaya abinayam kazhcha vechu.
technical department
camera - santhosh sivan career best ennu parayan pattunna prakadanam, oru pakshe rahmaneum santhosh sivaneyum ithra adhikam choshanam cheyyan kazhinjathayirikkum mani ratnathinu abimanikan kazhiyuka. oru enna chaya chithram pole manoharamanu santhosh sivante oro framesum.
music - arr enna genious orikkal koodi thante guruvinu amoolyamay oru guru dakshina nalkunnu, situationsinu yojicha eenangal orukkunnathil adheham vijayichirikkunnu, theatril rahman experience sharik ariyunnund.
editing/visual efxs - palapozhum edtingum arojakam ayi.oru re arrangement avshayamnu ennu thonniyekkam.visual efxum special efxum mikacha nilavaram pularthi, explosions and fire works mikacha reethiyil thanne chithrathil kanan kazhiyunnud.
re recording and sound efx _ ar rahmante re recording adhehathinte ganangale pole thanne mattoru geniousinte kayyopp akunnu. chithrathodoppam thanne ozhukinoppam thanne layichu cherunna bgm anu rahman nalkiyathu. sound efxine prathyakam abinandhikathe aya, gun shotukalum alari karachilukalum valare mikavutta reethiyil thanne sabdha lekhanam chethirikkunnu.
rathna churukkam
ar rahmanteyum santhosh sivantyum raavan kanan thayyarayi pokuka. valmeeki ramayanathinu pusthaka shalayil anweshikuka. mani ratnam enna master crafts manod thalkalam ksamikuka.
ratig: 2.5/5 ( strictly for arr & santhosh sivan , and the effort put in by all)
verdict: may end up as an average.
mone jada raju...mani sir, rahman, ash, 6 pack, thengakola, aana motta puzhungiyath...oduvil pavanayi shavamayi. PHA-yude prarthana phalichu.
just back afer watching Ravan with saroj and samurai, we had dinner together. saroj is with me in my flat now, he is having a hot tea, and the time is 3 am here, very difficult for a review.
theatre: lamcy cinemas, karama-dubai
show time : 11 pm
status: house full
mahis views
sadharana mani ratnam films kanan pokumbol ulla oru expectation undallo,athu athe pole thanne nila nirthi ennu njan parayum.
plot ivide binoy paranjallo, thudakkathile scenes ellam nalla interesting ayirunnu. ramayanam plot modern versionil avatharipichirikkunnu. ini njan kanda kure sthiram cliche scenes parayam.
eccentric and psycho aya oru nayakan, ayal onnukil ethenkilum kunninte mukalil kayari irikkum, athallenkil ethenkilum kallinmel kunthichiriikkum, kuracu neram silent ayi irikkum,pettennu alarum,athu ketu adthullavar njettum, samsarikkumbol idak kannu thuripichu kattum, alenkil pottichirikkum,aa pazhaya set up thanne. :deviltalk:
ee nayakanu tension vannal ayal mottathala thadavi kondirikkum, ayalude priyappettavar arenkilum marchal alari karayum, 2 kayyum thalayude pinnil pidich karayum, athum vaya paramavadhi polichu vechu.:thinking:
pinne mugathu pala color chayam thehcu varum, idak karupp, idak velup, idak manja, enthu pandarathinanavo ee chayam? veruthe manushyane menakeduthanayitu.:sathan:
inne pathiv pole nayakanu vendi ( atho villano) chakan nadakunna koottalikal, avar full time kattilayirikum, avarum mugath chayamoke thechanu nadakkunnath, ennal alle oru mani ratnam touch kittu? avanmaarum idakidak oliyitt kondirikkum,:haha:
nayakanu santhosham varumbol avarellavarum koode kattuvasikale pole kuntham pidichu thullichadum, idak kurach cheriya pillar screenlode odipkum, idak chila vayassaya ammoommamare kond 2 vari padipiku, avarude 2 stepsum, athu kure mani ratnam filmsil ullatnallo? camera idakidak ilakki konde irikkum, kanunnavanu enthanu nadakkunnath ennu oru vasthu manassilakaruthallo?:death:
pinne ee thatikondu pokal, athum nammal kure kandathu thanne, areyano thatti kond poyathu, avar gap kittumbol odipokum, avar ethu vazhiyiloode poyalum chennu pedunnath thati kondu ponna alude munpil ayirikum, ithilum athu thannekadha,:hbang:
njan koduthal onnum parayunnilla, nalla bangiyulla frames undayirunnu,music was good, after interwell anu onnu intersting ayath, climaxile fight nannnayirunnu.
climax was just above average.
perfomance
abhishek was ok
vikram was superb
aishaya as usual
govinda - natural
music and camera was really good.
mani ratnam athra valiya oru sambavam cheythu ennu enik thonniyilla,:roll:
media ithra hype kodukkunathum alkarude aswadhanathe badhikkunnund, enik ithil kooduthal onnum parayan aryilla.padathe kurichu adhikarikamayi samsarikkan njan sarojine vilikkunu.
my rating : 2/5
my verdict: flop :silenced:
sarojs view
adhyam thanne parayate, kanan pokunna cinemaye kurichu oru vyakthamaya dharana munp vanna vilayiruthalukalil ninnu kittiyathinalakam amthamaya pratheekshakalonnum illayirunnu, enkilum rahmante ganangalum sangeeth sivante framesum theatril thanne aswadhikkuka ennathu mathram ayirunnu lakshyam.
ini cinemayilek....
kadhasaram pala avarthi paranjathu kond kooduthal prathipadhikkunnilla, enkilum kadhayekuichu chilath parayaund. ramayanathil ninnu prajodhanam ulkondanu ee cinema cheythath ennu maniratnam avakashapedunnekilum ramayanathinte chla amshangal mathrame enik ithil kanan sadhicullu.padipathinja oru pazhamkadhayo punnyapurana mahakavyamo adarthi edth mattoru veekshana oniloode athine avatharipikumbol theerchayayum athinte saramshathod neethi pularthanam,alathavakonnum thanne asthiwtham undavilla.
malayalathil m.t chanthuvine puthiya oru thalathil avatharipichu vijayipichath nammal kandathanu, peredut oru porayma polum arayan akatha oru classic chithram, pakshe ivde mani ratnathinu ambe pali. oru kadha karante mano vijarathinu anusarichu kadhapathrangale engane venamenkilum matti marikam, nyakane villain akkam, villaine nayakan akanm, sahajaryangal kondu nyayeekarikkukayum avam. pakshe athorikkalum prerana ulkonda maha avyathinte ashayathine thanne natti prathishttikkunna reethyil akaruth.
kadhayilek...
kettathum paranjathumokke ravanante kannilode oru modern ramayanam ennayirunnu, enkilum arayatte, ee kadha enik ramyanam ayi kanan kazhiyunnilla.
udhaharanathinu ramayanathil raman ravananod yudham cheyyunath polum seethaye thatti kond poyi enna ru karanam ond mathramanu, pakshe maniratnathinte raman thangalude sakthi theliyikkan raqinte mel kadannu kayariya america pole , thante varavu ariyikkan, beerayod ( raavan) poruthan irangunna oru sadharana cinematic nayakan mathramayi othungi. athu kond thanne avanil ramante oru amshavum kanan enik kazhinjilla.
itharam oru sahajaryathiloode thanne mani ratnam cinemayle nayakan aya raavananu munthookam kodukuvanum athiloode raavanane nyayeekarikkanum attum. ee oru udhaharanathiloode thanne ethra mathram ravanante kadha ramayanathod chernnu nilkkunnu ennu vyakathamyennu karthunnu.
munkalaa mani ratnam chithramaya kadhathanthu enna andavum ranayanam enna beejavum ru test tubeil samyojipichu kalam thetti piravi kodutha oru mixtre mathramanu thinte kadha, spastamayennu karuthatte..
direction.
mani ratnam enna samvidhayakante oru pizhavanu ee chithrathinu ingane oru vidhi sammanikunnath. shaji kailasinu abimanikam, adhehathinpin thudaran mani ratnathe pole oru pragalba samvdhayakanum ethunnu. close up shotukalum , shaky camera movementsum abstract shotukalum ( dont know whether this term is correct), kond kadha parayan sramichath thanne prekshakanu maduppum ulavakkunnud. oru avasarathil oru arojakam ayi marunnund. oru pakshe kadha arayunna reethiyil oru puthuma ondu varan sramichathanenkil polum athu oru parajayam ayennuparaathe vaya.
perfomances.
abishek bachan - chila avsarangalil over the top ayi tonni enkilum muzhachu nilkatha abinayam.
vikram - pala thalangal illatha oru sadharana villain kadhapathrathe anayasamayi avatharipichu, enkilum chila scens manoharamayirunnu.
aiswaraya - facial expressionekal kooduthalum physical strain anu padathil kanan kazhinjath. enkilum mikachathenno mosham enno parayan pattatha oru perfomance.
co starsil govinda eduth payan thakka savisesathakal onnumillatha oru sadharana prakadanam, priyamani nannayirunnu, ravi kishan swatha sidhamaya abinayam kazhcha vechu.
technical department
camera - santhosh sivan career best ennu parayan pattunna prakadanam, oru pakshe rahmaneum santhosh sivaneyum ithra adhikam choshanam cheyyan kazhinjathayirikkum mani ratnathinu abimanikan kazhiyuka. oru enna chaya chithram pole manoharamanu santhosh sivante oro framesum.
music - arr enna genious orikkal koodi thante guruvinu amoolyamay oru guru dakshina nalkunnu, situationsinu yojicha eenangal orukkunnathil adheham vijayichirikkunnu, theatril rahman experience sharik ariyunnund.
editing/visual efxs - palapozhum edtingum arojakam ayi.oru re arrangement avshayamnu ennu thonniyekkam.visual efxum special efxum mikacha nilavaram pularthi, explosions and fire works mikacha reethiyil thanne chithrathil kanan kazhiyunnud.
re recording and sound efx _ ar rahmante re recording adhehathinte ganangale pole thanne mattoru geniousinte kayyopp akunnu. chithrathodoppam thanne ozhukinoppam thanne layichu cherunna bgm anu rahman nalkiyathu. sound efxine prathyakam abinandhikathe aya, gun shotukalum alari karachilukalum valare mikavutta reethiyil thanne sabdha lekhanam chethirikkunnu.
rathna churukkam
ar rahmanteyum santhosh sivantyum raavan kanan thayyarayi pokuka. valmeeki ramayanathinu pusthaka shalayil anweshikuka. mani ratnam enna master crafts manod thalkalam ksamikuka.
ratig: 2.5/5 ( strictly for arr & santhosh sivan , and the effort put in by all)
verdict: may end up as an average.
mone jada raju...mani sir, rahman, ash, 6 pack, thengakola, aana motta puzhungiyath...oduvil pavanayi shavamayi. PHA-yude prarthana phalichu.